ried them not at all。 That some of their deeply held beliefs might turn out to be mistakes was a possibility hardly considered。 Doctrinal humility was to be practiced by others。 Their own teachings were inerrant and Infallible。 In truth； they had better reason to be humble than they knew。
BEGINNING WITH COPERNICUS in the middle sixteenth century； the issue was formally joined。 The picture of the Sun rather than the Earth at the center of the Universe was understood to be dangerous。 Obligingly； many scholars were quick to assure the religious hierarchy that this newfangled hypothesis represented no serious challenge to conventional wisdom。 In a kind of split…brain promise； the Sun…centered system was treated as a mere putational convenience； not an astronomical reality that is； the Earth was really at the center of the Universe； as everybody knew； but if you wished to predict where Jupiter would be on the second Tuesday of November the year after next； you were permitted to pretend that the Sun was at the center。 Then you could calculate away and not affront the Authorities。*
* Copernicus' famous book was first published with an introduction by the theologian Andrew Osiander； inserted without the knowledge of the dying astronomer。 Osiander's well…meaning attempt to reconcile religion and Copernican astronomy ended with these words： 〃＇L＇et no one expect anything in the way of certainty of astronomy； since astronomy can offer us nothing certain； lest； if anyone take as true that which has been constructed for 。mother use； he go away from this discipline a bigger fool than w hen he cane to it。〃 Certainty could be found only in religion。
〃This has no danger in it；〃 wrote Robert Cardinal Bellarmine； the foremost Vatican theologian in the early seventeenth century； and suffices for the mathematicians。 But； to affirm that the Sun is really fixed in the center of the heavens and that the Earth revolves very swiftly around the Sun is a dangerous thing； not only irritating the theologians and philosophers； but injuring our holy faith and making the sacred scripture false。〃
〃Freedom of belief is pernicious；〃 Bellarmine wrote on another occasion。 〃It is nothing but the freedom to be wrong。〃
Besides； if the Earth was going around the Sun； nearby stars should seem to move against the background of more distant stars as； every six months； we shift our perspective from one side of the Earth's orbit to the other。 No such 〃annual parallax〃 had been found。 The Copernicans argued that this was because the stars were extremely far away—maybe a million times more distant than the Earth is from the Sun。 Perhaps better telescopes； in future times； would find an annual parallax。 The geocentrists considered this a desperate attempt to save a flawed hypothesis； and ludicrous on the face of it。
When Galileo turned the first astronomical telescope to the sky； the tide began to turn。 He discovered that Jupiter had a little retinue of moons circling it； the inner ones orbiting faster than the outer ones； just as Copernicus had deduced for the motion of the planets about the Sun。 He found that Mercury and Venus went through phases like the Moon （showing they orbited the Sun）。 Moreover； the cratered Moon and the spotted Sun challenged the perfection of the heavens。 This may in part constitute the sort of trouble Tertullian was worried about thirteen hundred years earlier； when he pleaded； 〃If you have any sense or modesty； have done with prying into the regions of the sky； into the destiny and secrets of the universe。〃
In contrast； Galileo taught that we can interrogate Nature by observation and experiment。 Then； 〃facts which at first sight seem improbable will； even on scant explanation； drop the cloak which had hidden them and stand forth in naked and simple beauty。〃 Are not these facts； available even for skeptics to
confirm； a surer insight into God's Universe than all the speculations of the theologians？ But what if these facts contradict the beliefs of those who hold their religion incapable of making mistakes？ The princes of the Church threatened the aged astronomer with torture if he persisted in teaching the abominable doctrine that the Earth moved。 He was sentenced to a kind of house arrest for the remainder of his life。
A generation or two later； by the time Isaac Newton demonstrated that simple and elegant physics could quantitatively explain—and predict—all the observed lunar and planetary motions （provided you assumed the Sun at the center of the Solar System）； the geocentrist conceit eroded further。
In 1725； in an attempt to discover stellar parallax； the painstaking English amateur astronomer James Bradley stumbled on the aberration of light。 The term 〃aberration；〃 I suppose； conveys something of the unexpectedness of the discovery。 When observed over the course of a year； stars were found to trace little ellipses against the sky。 But all the stars were found to do so。 This could not be stellar parallax； where we would expect a big parallax for nearby stars and an indetectible one for faraway stars。 Instead； aberration is similar to how raindrop falling directly down on a speeding auto seem to the passenger； to be falling at a slant； the faster the car goes； the steeper the slant。 If the Earth were stationary at the center of the Universe。 and not speeding in its orbit around the Sun； Bradley would nor have found the aberration of light。 It was a pelling demonstration that the Earth revolved about the Sun。 It convinced most astronomers and some others but not； Bradley thought； the 〃Anti…Copernicans。〃
But not until 1837 did direct observations of the stars prove in the clearest way that the Earth is indeed circling the Sun。 The long…debated annual parallax was at last discovered—not by better arguments； but by better instruments。 Because explaining what it means is much more straightforward than explaining the aberration of light； its discovery was very important。 It pounded the final nail into the coffin of geocentrism。 You need only look at your finger with your left eye and then with your right and see it seem to move。 Everyone can understand parallax。
By the nineteenth century； all scientific geocentrists had been converted or rendered extinct。 Once most scientists had been convinced； informed public opinion had swiftly changed； in some countries in a mere three or four generations。 Of course； in the time of Galileo and Newton and even much later； there were still some who objected； who tried to prevent the new Sun…centered Universe from being accepted； or even known。 And there were many who at least harbored secret reservations。
By the late twentieth century； just in case there were any holdouts； we have been able to settle the matter directly。 We've been able to test whether we live in an Earth…centered system with planets affixed to transparent crystal spheres； or in a Sun…centered system with planets controlled at a distance by the gravity of the Sun。 We have； for example； probed the planets with radar。 When we bounce a signal off a moon of Saturn； we receive no radio echo from a nearer crystal sphere attached to Jupiter。 Our spacecraft arrive at their appointed destinations with astonishing precision； exactly as predicted by Newtonian gravitation。 When our ships fly to Mars； say； their instruments do not hear a tinkling sound or detect shards of broken crystal as they crash through the 〃spheres〃 that—according to the authoritative opinions that prevailed for millennia—propel Venus or the Sun ill their dutiful motions about the central Earth。
When Voyager 1 scanned the Solar System from beyond the outermost planet； it saw； just as Copernicus and Galileo had said we would； the Sun in the middle and the planets in concentric orbits about it。 Far from being the center of the Universe； the Earth is just one of the orbiting dots。 No longer confined to a single world； we are now able to reach out to others and determine decisively what kind of planetary system we inhabit。
EVERY OTHER PROPOSAL； and their number is legion； to displace us from cosmic center stage has also been resisted； in part for similar reasons。 We seem to crave privilege； merited not by our work； but by our birth； by the mere